There’s just no beating the delicious, thick pizzas from this popular pizzeria. Papa John’s serves up warm, delicious family favorites with perfect toppings and even better sauces. But with sauces at Domino’s and sauces at Little Caesars being equally tasty, what sauces does Papa John’s have that can match them?
Papa John’s feature some tasty sauces like a BBQ Dipping Sauce, Buffalo Spicy Dipping Sauce, Spicy Garlic Sauce, and Blue Cheese Dipping Sauce. But these aren’t the only Papa John’s sauces available, so let’s get tucked in!
📌 Papa John’s Sauces Nutrition
| Papa John’s Sauces | Calories | Allergens |
| BBQ Dipping Sauce | 45 | N/A |
| Blue Cheese Dipping Sauce | 15 | Egg, Milk |
| Buffalo Spicy Dipping Sauce | 40 | N/A |
| Cheese Dipping Sauce | 40 | Egg, Milk, Soy |
| Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce | 150 | Egg |
| Special Garlic Sauce | 140 | Egg, Mustard |
| Pizza Sauce Dipping Cup | 20 | N/A |
| Ranch Dipping Sauce | 100 | Egg, Milk |
| Spicy Garlic Sauce | 154 | Egg, Mustard |
| Cream Cheese Icing | 180 | Milk |
| Honey Chipotle Dipping Sauce | 140 | Milk, Wheat |
| Special Zesty Dipping Sauce | 150 | Egg |
💡 All Sauces of Papa John’s
BBQ Dipping Sauce
You can’t mention Papa John’s sauces and not include their classic BBQ dipping sauce. This tasty blend of molasses, brown sugar, and spices gives a perfect sweet and smoky flavor combo for just 45 calories. The delicious tangy and savory flavors make for a rich and thick dip for their Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza, Chicken Poppers, Parmesan Crusted BBQ Chicken & Bacon Papadia, and Chicken Wings.
Buffalo Spicy Dipping Sauce
It could be wings, it could be their chicken poppers, whatever it is, this is one of Papa John’s sauces for all. The Buffalo Spicy Sauce has everything great going for it, with a delicious fiery and tangy blend of vinegar, aged red pepper, garlic, paprika, and spices for just 15 calories. Using some great ways to thicken buffalo sauce, they made a spicy and thick coating that’s perfect as a sauce for Chicken Wings, Chicken Poppers, The Meats Pizza, and Meatball Pepperoni Pizza.
Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce
The king of classic sauces. Papa John’s Honey Mustard dipping sauce mixes everything you love about honey with the spicy, sharp tang of mustard. It’s a tough competitor for McDonald’s sauce lineup version, with a blend of soybean oil, prepared mustard, honey, and egg yolks that packs just 150 calories. A tasty little treat for their Meats Pizza, Meatball Pepperoni Pizza, and Chicken Poppers.
Special Garlic Sauce
A creamy, rich sauce that’s rightly named so. The Special Garlic Sauce at Papa John’s is a delicious blend of creaminess and garlicky goodness with a fantastic subtle butteriness. Its simple blend of salt, spices, garlic, and soybean oil with other tasty special ingredients makes for a perfect Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza, Meatball Pepperoni Pizza, and Breadsticks dip.
Cheese Dipping Sauce
You can’t top pure creaminess and cheesiness. It’s one of the cheesiest sauces at Papa John’s, with a delicious thick blend of rich Jack cheese, soybean oil, and spices. The creamy, thick texture comes from them using some great techniques to thicken cheese sauce. This allows a consistency that oozes a tasty flavor that’s matched by its low calories of just 40. A creamy delight that just has to be paired with Papa John’s Breadsticks and Tuscan 6-cheese Cheesesticks.
Blue Cheese Dipping Sauce
Cheesy deliciousness just got even better with Papa John’s Blue Cheese dipping sauce. This creamy and indulgent delight packs 160 calories with its ranch-like creaminess and rich blue cheese goodness. Its delicious ingredient blend of soybean oil, blue cheese, egg yolks, buttermilk, and spices is a perfect flavor pairing for any of their Chicken Poppers, Chicken Wings, and Parmesan Crusted Philly Cheesesteak Papadia.
Ranch Dipping Sauce
There’s nothing quite like the rich, creamy tanginess of a classic ranch sauce. It’s one of Papa John’s sauces that you just need to try! It packs every bit of that classic ranch flavor and more! The sauce has a tasty herby flavor with delicious creamy tanginess, all for just 100 calories. It even has a tasty thick creaminess that makes for a perfect sauce for chicken like their Grilled Buffalo Chicken Papadia, Jalapeño Popper Rolls, and Buffalo Chicken Pizza.
Pizza Sauce Dipping Cup
Tomatoey tanginess with a delicious, rich texture. Papa John’s Pizza Sauce has it all. Its classic blend of fresh vine-ripened tomatoes, sunflower oil, garlic, and a mixture of spices makes for a tasty, thick dip at just 20 calories. It can even be a delicious marinara substitute with an all-rounder taste that’s rich and tangy with thick chunkiness that’s just perfect for their pizzas and breadsticks.
Spicy Garlic Sauce
You have the special garlic sauce, now you have its fiery and delicious cousin. Papa John’s Spicy Garlic sauce stuffs its traditional garlic sauce blend with red chilies and jalapeños. All this delicious flavor comes in at just 154 calories, adding a perfect garlicky kick to Breadsticks, Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza, Tuscan 6 Cheese Pizza, and Parmesan Crusted Meatball Pepperoni Papadia.
Cream Cheese Icing
Papa John’s loves its cheese dips, and its sweet, cream cheese icing fusion tops them all. The creaminess, the sweet, delicious flavors, and the rich, cheesy undertone make for the perfect dessert topping. You can’t get any better than that! With just 180 calories, it’s a thick and creamy companion for Papa John’s Cinnamon Pull Apart and their 8″ Mega Chocolate Chip Cookie.
Honey Chipotle Dipping Sauce
If the Honey Mustard Sauce flavor combo wasn’t enough, then have a bash with the spicy Honey Chipotle Dipping Sauce. This tasty sauce takes the best flavors of chipotle and mixes them with the sweet goodness of honey. The smoky heat, the rich sweetness, and the delicious spice are packed into just 140 calories. Its smooth and thick texture is just perfect for their Papa’s Chicken Wings and Parmesan Crusted Philly Cheesesteak Papadia.
Special Zesty Dipping Sauce
Like most of the delicious special sauces at Papa John’s, there’s another tasty addition to their lineup. The tasty Special Zesty Sauce. This fantastic sauce gives you that smooth, creamy texture with perfect zesty notes and Italian seasoning. At just 150 calories, a small splash of this will make for a superb flavor pairing for their Zesty Italian Trio Pizza, Chicken Wings, and Chicken Poppers sauce side.
🧐 FAQs
Papa John’s has two vegan sauce options, which are the original pizza sauce and the BBQ sauce. Both of these sauces are vegan, meaning they do not contain any animal products or byproducts.
Unfortunately, Papa John’s does not currently sell their sauces in bottles. However, you can still enjoy their delicious sauces by ordering from their menu.
Papa John’s offers gluten-free options for their sauces, including the pizza sauce, BBQ sauce, and hot buffalo sauce.
The most popular sauce at Papa John’s is their original pizza sauce. Other popular sauces include the garlic sauce and the BBQ sauce.
Yes, Papa John’s pizza comes with a garlic dipping sauce, which is included as a non-negotiable item with every order. Customers will receive the garlic cup unless they specifically request to have it left out. There is no option to swap it out for any other sauce without an additional cost.